Historical recipe: Marlborough pie

Published: March 14, 2019 at 2:51 PM

Difficulty 5/10

Total time: 1 hr and 40 mins

In every issue of BBC History Magazine, picture editor Sam Nott brings you a recipe from the past. In this article, Sam recreates marlborough pie – a tasty pie that travelled to America in the 17th century

Skip to ingredients

English chef Robert May created this apple custard pie when compiling dishes for his 1660 recipe book The Accomplisht Cook. As the English established colonies in the New World during the 17th century, settlers took the pie recipe with them. Since the 19th century it has become a favourite dessert in the US during holidays such as Thanksgiving.

The original recipe includes equal quantities of egg, apple and dry sherry. I used a modified recipe to ensure the right taste and cooking time.

Ingredients

For the pastry

180g Strong bread flour
1tbsp Granulated sugar
½tsp Salt
125g Unsalted butter

chilled and cut into cubes
3tbsp Ice cold water

For the filling

1 ½ Bramley cooking apples

peeled and grated
3tbsp Lemon juice
3tbsp Dry sherry
30g Salted butter
140g Granulated sugar
3 Eggs

(large)
240ml Single cream
¼tsp Ground cinnamon
¼tsp Grated nutmeg
¼tsp Salt

Method

Pastry
step 1

Put the flour, salt and sugar in a bowl. Work the butter cubes into the flour with fingers until the mixture looks crumbly.
step 2

Add water to make dough. Knead the dough on a lightly floured surface until smooth. Roll into a ball and cover in cling film. Refrigerate for 30 minutes.
Filling
step 3

Place the grated apple in a bowl and stir in lemon juice and sherry. Melt the butter in a pan and add apple mixture and sugar. Allow the liquid to boil. Reduce heat and stir until most of the liquid has evaporated. Cool for 10 mins.
step 4

Preheat the oven to 200°C. Line a 9 inch pie tin with baking parchment. Roll the dough into a 10 inch circle, 1/8 inch thick. Place in the pie tin and fold excess onto edge of tin to make a crust. Prick the dough and blind bake for 10 minutes. Remove weights and parchment and bake for another 5 minutes.
step 5

Reduce oven temperature to 180°C. Whisk together the eggs, cream, cinnamon, nutmeg and salt, and add apple mixture. Pour the filling into the pastry. Bake for 35 minutes until the custard is set but not too brown.

Discover more historical recipes, including:

Historical recipe: Marlborough pie

Ingredients

For the pastry

For the filling

Method

Pastry

step 1

step 2

Filling

step 3

step 4

step 5